Downscaling satellite-derived soil moisture products based on soil
thermal inertia: a comparison of three models over a semi-arid catchment
in south-eastern Australia
Abstract
High spatial resolution soil moisture information is important for
regional–scale hydrologic, climatic and agricultural applications.
However, available point-scale in-situ measurements and coarse-scale
(~10s of km) satellite soil moisture retrievals are
unable to capture hillslope to sub-catchment level spatial variability
of soil moisture as required by many of these applications. Downscaling
L-band satellite soil moisture retrievals appears to be a viable
technique in estimating near surface (~ top 5 cm) soil
moisture at a high spatial resolution. Among different downscaling
approaches, thermal data based methods exhibits a good potential over
arid and semi-arid regions, i.e. in many parts of Australia. This study
investigates three downscaling approaches based on soil thermal inertia
to estimate near surface soil moisture at high spatial resolution (1 km)
over Krui and Merriwa River catchments in the Upper Hunter region of New
South Wales, Australia. These methods are based upon the relationship
between the diurnal soil temperature difference (ΔT) and daily mean soil
moisture content (μSM). Regression tree models between ΔT and μSM were
developed by using in-situ observations (in the first approach) and
using land surface model (LSM) based estimates (in the second approach).
The relationship between ΔT and μSM was modulated by the vegetation
density and the Austral season. In the in-situ data based approach, soil
texture was also employed as a modulating factor. These in-situ datasets
were obtained from the Scaling and Assimilation of Soil Moisture and
Streamflow (SASMAS) network and model-based estimates from the Global
Land Data Assimilation System (GLDAS). Moderate Resolution Imaging
Spectroradiometer (MODIS) derived Normalized Difference Vegetation Index
(NDVI) products were used to define vegetation density. An ensemble
machine-learning model was employed in the third approach using ΔT, NDVI
and Austral season as predictors and μsm values as responses. Aggregated
airborne soil moisture retrievals were used as the coarse resolution
soil moisture products. These coarse resolution soil moisture
simulations were downscaled to 1 km by employing the above three
approaches using MODIS-derived ΔT and NDVI values. The results from the
three downscaling methods were compared against the 1 km soil moisture
retrievals from the National Airborne Field Experiment 2005 (NAFE’05)
over 3 days in November 2005. The results from both in-situ data and
GLDAS-based regression tree models show RMSEs of 0.07 cm3/cm3 when
compared against the high resolution NAFE’05 airborne soil moisture
observations. The GLDAS-based model can be applied over a larger extent,
whereas the in-situ data based model is catchment specific. These
results were compared with the results from the machine-learnt model. A
combination of these methods with additional forcing factors such as
topography, meteorology, etc. can be utilized to develop an improved
downscaling model. Such a mod