Wintering Together: Do migrants impact residents? A literature review.
Abstract
Year after year, billions of long-distance migratory birds join
year-round resident tropical birds during the overwintering period (dry
season in the tropics) marked by harsh environmental conditions. The
overlapping habitat use and apparent resource overlap during this time
suggest potential interspecific competition between residents and
migrants. Previous studies have explored the effects of such competition
on migrants, but the impact on residents has been neglected. This review
critically evaluates and summarizes the findings in the literature about
interactions between migratory and resident birds in tropical
ecosystems, using the necessary and sufficient conditions recommended by
Dhondt 2012 to assess interspecific competition. This review reveals
that interspecific territoriality, consistent aggression (interference
competition), and alterations in foraging behavior and microhabitat
impacted resident birds. High dietary overlap observed in some species
pairs suggests potential exploitation competition, although our
understanding of year-round residents’ diets and the full scope of these
interactions remains limited. The complexity of these relationships
underscores the need for comprehensive research to disentangle seasonal
effects from competitive pressures and to assess impacts on resident
fitness, distribution, and abundance. Inconsistent methodologies and
inadequate spatio-temporal scales have hindered a clear understanding of
this phenomenon. We emphasize the importance of long-term studies,
including observations before and after migrant arrival at wintering
grounds, to detect shifts in resource availability and foraging niches.
Given climate change’s influence on migration patterns and food
resources, elucidating these biotic interactions is crucial for
developing effective conservation strategies for resident tropical
avifauna. Particularly, as many resident birds exhibit high levels of
endemism, higher sedentarism, and specialized foraging habits, they may
be more vulnerable to ecological changes than migrants, who are more
flexible, generally occupying broader foraging niches. This review
highlights critical knowledge gaps and proposes directions for future
research to enhance our understanding of migrant-resident bird dynamics
in tropical ecosystems.