Adding nebulized to systemic corticosteroids for acute asthma in
children: a meta-analysis
Abstract
International guidelines have recommended the use of inhaled beta-2
agonists and systemic corticosteroids (SC) as the first-line treatment
for acute asthma. Objective: To evaluate the evidence for the efficacy
of inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) in addition to SC compared to SC alone
in children with acute asthma in the ED or during hospitalization. Data
sources: Five electronic databases were searched. Study Selection: All
RCTs that compared ICS (via nebulizer or metered dose inhaler) plus SC
(oral or parenteral) with placebo (or standard care) plus SC were
included without language restriction. Data extraction: Two reviewers
independently reviewed all studies. The primary outcomes were hospital
admission or hospital length of stay [LOS], and secondary outcomes
were readmissions during follow-up, ED-LOS, lung function, asthma
clinical score, oxygen saturation, and heart and respiratory rates.
Results: Nine studies (n=1473) met the inclusion criteria. In all the
studies, the ICS was budesonide. Compared to SC alone, adding budesonide
to SC did not affect hospitalization rate, but decreased hospital LOS by
more than one day (MD= -29.08 hours [-39.9 to -18.3]; I2=0%,
p=<0.00001). Moreover, adding budesonide (especially with ≥2mg
doses) significantly improved the acute asthma severity score among
patients at ED. Conclusions: Compared to SC alone, adding budesonide to
SC did not affect hospitalization rate, but decreases the LOS and
improves the acute asthma score in children at ED setting.