A tale of two species: climate-competition tradeoffs shape range limits
according to tree life-history strategies
Abstract
Adapting for competitiveness versus climatic stress tolerance
constitutes a primary trade-off differentiating tree life-history
strategies. This tradeoff likely influences where species’ range-limits
occur, but such links are data-demanding to study and key mechanisms
lack empirical support. Using an exceptionally rich dendroecological
network, we assessed spatial variation in climate and competition
effects on Picea abies and Fagus sylvatica throughout the Carpathian
Ecoregion. Ring width synchrony aided in diagnosing how the prevalence
of resource-limited (competition) and sink-limited (climate) growth
changes with altitude and community composition. Contrasting growth
patterns towards respective upper and lower range limits of Fagus and
Picea reflected tradeoffs between competitive vs. cold-tolerant
strategies. Fagus performance declined with altitudinal increases in
climate sensitivity, but improved under interspecific competition. Picea
growth increased towards the species’ lower range limit, but declined
under interspecific competition. Warmer temperatures likely benefit
competitively stronger species at mid elevations and thus imply range
reductions for alpine conifers.