Inducible defenses of prey are evolved under diverse and variable predation risks. However, during the co-evolution of prey and multiple predators, the responses of prey to antagonistic predation risks, which may put the prey into a dilemma of responding to predators, remain unclear. Based on antagonistic predation pressure from an invertebrate (Chaoborus larvae) and a vertebrate (Rhodeus ocellatus) predator, we studied the responses of multiple traits and transcriptomes of the freshwater crustacean Ceriodaphnia cornuta under multiple predation risks. Chaoborus predation risk altered the expression of genes encoding cuticle proteins and modulated the biosynthesis of steroid hormones, cutin, suberine, and wax, leading to the development of horns and increase in size at the late developmental stage. Meanwhile, fish predation risk primarily triggered genes encoding ribosomes and those involved in unsaturated fatty acid biosynthesis and cysteine and methionine metabolism, resulting in smaller individual size and earlier reproduction. Inducible responses of both transcriptome and individual traits revealed that predator-dependent unique responses were dominant and the dilemma of antagonistic responses was relatively limited. However, the unique individual traits in response to invertebrate predation could be significantly impaired by vertebrate predation risk, even though the unique responses to different predators were extremely weakly correlated and could be elicited simultaneously. These results indicate that diverse predator-dependent unique responses are favored by Ceriodaphnia during its co-evolution with multiple predators. Nonetheless, Ceriodaphnia is not a generalist that can fully adopt all predator-dependent unique responses simultaneously under multiple predation risks.

Inducible defenses of prey are evolved under diverse and variable predation risks. In the co-evolution of prey and multiple predators with antagonistic selection pressures, whether inducible defense responses of prey will fall into a dilemma and its underlying mechanism are still unclear. Based on the antagonistic predation pressure from invertebrate predator Chaoborus larvae and vertebrate predator fish, we studied multi-traits and transcriptome of the freshwater crustacean Ceriodaphnia cornuta under multiple predation risks. Our results showed that Chaoborus larvae predation risks altered the expression of genes encoding cuticle protein and changed the biosynthesis of steroid hormone, cutin, suberine, and wax, promoting Ceriodaphnia to express horns and grow larger at a late development stage, whereas fish predation risks mainly triggered responses in genes encoding ribosome and pathways of unsaturated fatty acids biosynthesis, cysteine and methionine metabolism, resulting in a smaller individual size and earlier reproduction. The inducible responses on transcription and individual traits both revealed that predator unique responses are dominant and the antagonistic responses are the least. Besides, Pearson correlations between different predator unique responses are extremely weak. Furthermore, the unique individual traits triggered by different predators can be expressed simultaneously. These results indicated that Ceriodaphnia can avoid the dilemma by performing predator unique responses and diverse inducible responses are favored in the co-evolution of zooplankton and multiple predators.