Waves, rivers, and tides play a leading role in shaping delta morphology. Recent studies have enabled predictions of their relative influence for deltas globally, but methods and associated uncertainties have remained poorly described. Here we aim to address that gap and assess the quality of delta morphology predictions compared to observations for 31 deltas globally. We expand on seminal works that quantified the Galloway ternary diagram from the balance between river, wave, and tidal sediment fluxes. Our data includes uncertainties for delta shoreline protrusion angles set by wave influence (14.1°±12° predicted vs. 20.8°±16.1° observed), channel widening, set by tidal influence (53.5±170.8 predicted vs. 6.5±11.5 observed), and number of distributary channels, set by river influence (55.9±127.5 predicted vs. 21.4±43.0 observed). Within the ternary diagram for delta morphology, we find an average error of 8% (±11%, 1 standard deviation), linked to uncertainties in wave and tide sediment fluxes. Relative uncertainties are greatest for mixed-process deltas (e.g., Sinu, error of 49%) and tend to decrease for end-member morphologies where either one of wave, tide, or river sediment fluxes dominates (e.g., Fly, error of 0.2%). Large sources of prediction uncertainties are (1) delta morphology data, e.g., delta slopes that modulate tidal fluxes, (2) data on river sediment flux distribution between individual delta river mouths, and (3) theoretical basis behind fluvial and tidal dominance. Future work could help address these three sources and improve predictions of delta morphology.

Connor Broaddus

and 3 more

Wave-influenced deltas are the most abundant delta type and are also potentially the most at-risk to human-caused changes, owing to the effects of wave-driven sediment transport processes and the short timescales on which they operate. Despite this, the processes controlling wave-influenced growth are poorly understood, and the role of fine-grained cohesive sediment (mud) is typically neglected. Here we simulate idealized river deltas in Delft3D across a range of conditions to interrogate how relative wave-influence and fluvial sediment composition impact delta evolution on decadal-millennial timescales. Our simulations capture the barrier-spit formation and accretion process characteristic of prograding wave-influenced deltas, such as those of the Red (Vietnam), Sinu (Colombia), and Coco (Nicaragua) rivers. Barrier-spit accretion exhibits multi-decadal cyclicity driven by subaqueous accumulation of fluvial sediment near river mouths. Using a range of metrics, we quantify how waves and mud influence delta morphology and dynamics. Results show that waves stabilize and simplify channel networks, smooth shorelines, increase shoreline reworking rates, reduce mud retention in the delta plain, and rework mouth bar sediments to form barrier-spits. Higher fluvial mud concentrations produce simpler and more stable distributary networks, rougher shorelines, and limit back-barrier lagoon preservation without altering shoreline reworking rates. Our findings reveal distinct controls on shoreline change between river-dominated and wave-influenced deltas and demonstrate that mud plays a critical role in delta evolution, even under strong wave influence. These insights could enhance paleoenvironmental reconstructions and inform predictions of delta responses to climate and land-use changes.